USGS Does The Right Thing, While Corps Doesn’t Share

August 29th, 2008 by Loki

Dear New Orleanians,

While the Corps of Engineers refuses to give up its storm surge prediction results, other branches of the government are not nearly so stingy.

The U.S. Geological Survey USGS), obviously a far more open, service-oriented organization, is setting up real-time surge level monitors on the shore of Lake Pontchartrain and other places around the New Orleans area starting tomorrow (Aug 30) as Gustav approaches. The public will be able to track what happens in the lake and elsewhere across the metro region in real time.

Not only that, but they are making the data available to the entire world via a super-easy Google Earth interface, available here.

There’s more detail in this USGS press release.

Here’s the USGS’s complete Gustav page.

Meanwhile, here’s the Corps’ online efforts in advance of Gustav, a self-congratulatory newsletter of use to no one.

Great job USACE! That’s far more informative than storm surge predictions…Matt McBride

Bookmark and Share

Corps surge model results for Gustav - please release to the public

August 27th, 2008 by Loki

Dear Corps officials, (as well as government representatives, New Orleanians, and media representatives),

I am writing you to make a request. In light of the possible effects of Hurricane/Tropical Storm Gustav upon the Greater New Orleans area, I would ask that the Corps and its partners at LSU and the Universtity of North Carolina make public the results of storm surge model runs which are (or soon will be) created as part of the Lake Pontchartrain Forecast System (LPFS).

As I understand it, the Corps has contracted with UNC’s Institute of Marine Sciences (contracts W912P8-06-P-0334 (from 2006, for $279,117) and W912P8-08-P-0082 (from earlier in 2008, for $101,512)) and their partners at LSU to provide forecasts of surge levels within Lake Pontchartrain when tropical systems are approaching New Orleans. This enables the Corps to determine when to lower the gates at the three interim closure structures along the Lake Pontchartrain south shore. The system is explained on a few webpages at LSU:

http://www.cct.lsu.edu/site38.php

http://www.cct.lsu.edu/~estrabd/LPFS/

http://www.cct.lsu.edu/~estrabd/LPFS/distributed-lpfs.pdf

http://www.cct.lsu.edu/~gallen/Preprints/CS_Allen07a.pre.pdf

In light of the Corps’ “12 Actions For Change,” specifically Action Number 9, “Effectively Communicate Risk,” it would be tremendous goodwill gesture to the public across the country to know what the Corps knows about the surge risk before the storm makes landfall.

Doing so would be in the same spirit that allows the National Hurricane Center and other organizations to make the results of hurricane track and intensity model runs available to public. Doing so allows government agencies and members of the public to plan more effectively, and allows the media to get more accurate information out to the public as they plan.

As part of your public outreach during the coming days, I urge you to upload the model results to your website so that everyone can be apprised of this vital information which will inform your decisions.

Best regards,
Matt McBride

Bookmark and Share

DC Endangered by Crappy Levees, Go Figure

July 25th, 2008 by Loki

A reader in Cincinnatti, OH who used to live in New Orleans Pre-Katrina graced my in-box with the following email message. I will write about this later once I have more time. In the meantime the RadiantAchangelus pretty much sums it all up:

Wait, Washington D.C. is below sea level? And filled with historic monuments? And barely protected by crappy old levees? Gee, sounds like a city I know. But quick - don’t fix the levees - they should just move too!!

Gaps in aging levees leave D.C. landmarks exposed - Yahoo! News

Of course if that is not enough here is a teaser from the article itself:

The small berm is part of an inconspicuous levee system designed to protect world-famous museums, the National Archives and federal office buildings from flooding.

But the nearly 70-year-old levee is at risk of failing during a major storm — a catastrophe that could swamp portions of downtown in up to 10 feet of water and cause $200 million in damages, according to federal officials.

Dozens of communities coast to coast are facing similar warnings as authorities re-examine the nation’s outdated flood-control infrastructure.

And one final ominous bit of foreshadowing I was heretofore unaware of (emphasis mine):

During six previous floods, officials placed sandbags on 17th Street, which cuts across the National Mall near the Washington Monument. Had there been more serious flooding, plans called for erecting an 8-foot earthen embankment with dirt taken from the grounds of the Washington Monument, said Steve Garbarino, the Corps’ project manager for flood protection in the Washington region.

This is Your Nation. This is Your Nation surrounded by failing levees. Any Questions?

Thanks R! We miss you down here!

Bookmark and Share

stop me if you’ve heard this one before

June 20th, 2008 by Louis Maistros

Yes, please do stop me if you’ve heard this one before. Because the punch line stinks.

Spoiler alert:

(photo by Louis Maistros, copyright 2006)

The italic bits are from the Associated Press, June 14, 2008. Stay with me. I’m trying to sort this out for myself as I go.

The dark, filthy water that flooded Iowa’s second-largest city finally started to recede Saturday after forcing 24,000 people to flee, but those who remained were urged to cut back on showering and flushing to save the last of their unspoiled drinking water.”

This does sound familiar, but keep going, maybe it’s just kinda-sorta familiar but not really.

“President Bush was briefed on the flooding in Iowa and other parts of the Midwest while he was in Paris, and was assured that federal agencies are making plans to help people affected by the high water…”

Yes, this does ring a bell. Because I remember how it was ok to do very little, way too late, or, really, nothing at all, as long as a person in a position of ultimate authority told us they have been officially assured by some vague figure employed by a vaguely referenced government agency that someone who knows someone is most assuredly (if vaguely) making plans to do something, vaguely, about this currently very specific and not vague-at-all problem that’s destroying lives, homes and families right here in the good old USA even as I type this. It’s like a memory of a dream of a memory of a plan of a dream of plan of a plan. Shit, I’m getting dizzy here. But wait, there’s more…

“He expressed his concern for people who may still be in danger and for those who are hurting from the impact of the storms…”

Yes, I clearly remember a fleeting warm fuzzy feeling that manifested itself in the midst of a traveling nervous breakdown. It hit me fuzzily on the road to God knows where after hearing widespread reports of genuine heartfelt concern from the president – but the feeling came and went so quickly I’m not sure if it was real or a dream now. Keep going, it’s a sort of déjà vu, but I need to be sure…

“The levee broke in two places,” said Keithsburg Alderman George Askew, 76. “We’re getting under water.”

OK, this part I remember.

“Since I’ve been involved in public office we’ve not seen this kind of devastation,” Obama said of the Midwest flooding. He vowed to push the federal and state governments to provide needed aid to the stricken areas.

Oh, Senator Obama; you wound me, sir. You know I love you, baby, but I’m pretty sure you were “involved in public office” in August of 2005. But thank you so much for noticing the Iowa flood, and for vowing to “push” for help there, and I hope you remember this one in three years time. I hear you even filled a few sandbags for the cameras – you’re catching on quick to this campaign trail stuff; good for you. If only you remembered about the 2005 thing, if only anyone “in pubic office” remembered, maybe things would be going a little smoother over in Iowa right now. You know, all that “we must learn from history or be doomed to repeat it” horseshit?

“Things happened really fast,” said Toby Hunvemuller of the Army Corps of Engineers. “We tried to figure out how high the level would go. Not enough time. We lost ground.”

Yes, that I remember as well. These things do happen very fast, don’t they? It’s why all these vague plans and preparations need to be a little less vague. But still, it’s nice to know the folks in charge of this stuff are at least very concerned. Really, all that concern after the fact just fixes everything right up. In fact, all you need is love. This must be true because I heard it in a song once.

And here is that stank-ass punch line that I hoped never to hear again, or, as my friend John Doheny says, the money quote:

“Authorities knew the aging levee near Birdland, a working-class, racially diverse neighborhood, was the weakest link among the city’s levees. A 2003 Corps report called for nearly $10 million in improvements across Des Moines, but there wasn’t enough federal money to do all the work.”

Bada bing, bada bang, bada boom. And there it is. Total recall. Just like here, they knew this was coming and did nothing. Even AFTER what happened here, so freshly in everyone’s minds, knowing full well how bad it can get.

The real kick in the pants is that, according to the “Corps Report” mentioned by AP, all Iowa needed to prevent this heartbreaking disaster was $10 million. Does that seem like a lot of money? Guess what, its’ not. Louisiana needs billions. $10 million is chicken feed. Bill Gates lost $10 million dollars while sneezing this morning and didn’t even miss it. It came right out his left nostril along with a Cheerio or two. This could have been prevented with relative ease.

There was “not enough federal money to do all the work?”

The war in Iraq costs US taxpayers $341.1 million dollars PER DAY.

All Iowa needed was $10 million to prevent catastrophic flooding that the authorities KNEW was bound to happen. 10 million dollars is the equivalent of a 20 minute coffee break in “the war on terror.”

Does widespread devastation at home not count as “terror”? For chrissakes, will someone get a cup of coffee already?

Are we really that much more afraid of a handful of psychopaths armed with box cutters than we are of a potentially endless series of ticking time bombs built by our own government and planted on our own soil?

You know, we in the gulf region like to take a small comfort in believing that what happened here in 2005 might not have been in vain if only those in power were to take the lesson learned, do their goddamn jobs, and try very hard to make sure it doesn’t happen again – here or anywhere else.

My heart goes out to the people in Iowa whose lives have been needlessly devastated this past week. I won’t play the “our disaster was bigger than your disaster game” because that game is bullshit. If you lost a loved one, or a home, or a livelihood, then you can give a rat’s ass about the statistics. It’s just a bunch of fucking numbers. The bottom line is this: it happened. And it didn’t have to.

One can only hope that the levees in Iowa are at least not stuffed with old newspaper as they apparently are here.

I hate to say what I feel I must say. Forgive me, but here it is:

For those who lined up to laugh at and mock the people of New Orleans for their “stupidity” in living in a city below sea level, who said shit like, “why don’t they all just get up and move to higher ground?”, that we should move from a place called home, a place we love, a place that existed and thrived a hundred years before America was even born – can you really look at what happened in Iowa and still believe all or any of that heartless bullshit you threw at us? Wouldn’t it be more productive to simply take a massive crap in your own hat?

The common thread here isn’t in the unpredictability of Mother Nature. The common thread is the bad, incomplete, poorly designed, poorly implemented, and badly kept structures brought to you by our own Army Corps of Engineers. And the jackasses in Congress, in the Senate, and in the White House who refuse again and again to give money back to taxpayers in the form they need it most; towards the basic protection of American citizens in their own homes.

This time it was a levee. Last time it was levee. Next time it might be a bridge. Or a highway. Or a damn. I bet you have one of those near you, wherever you are in America.

The Army Corps of Engineers is immune from prosecution for their actions or inactions; even if the damage is ruled malicious, even if they knowingly create faulty structures; lie about it, then actively covers up these facts. There need to be new laws on the books that hold them, and all government agencies, accountable for their actions. Otherwise they can do whatever the hell they want and thumb their noses at us while they snicker behind our backs and tell us how concerned they are about our shattered lives.

You are probably thinking: What can I do except hope it isn’t me next?

If you really believe there’s nothing you can do, the jig is up. The bad guys win. Game over.

Please don’t ask me for instructions. Use your imagination.

(Note: Click here for the full article quoted in this entry)

***

Cross-posted from These Things May Not Be Right, But They Are True.

http://louismaistros.com


The Sound of Building Coffins by Louis Maistros is due for publication from The Toby Press in Spring 2009.

Bookmark and Share

More on seepage - and what the Corps is holding back

June 12th, 2008 by Loki

Once more HumidCity is proud to syndicate the emails of engineer Matt McBride, the man who formerly helmed Fix The Pumps.

Dear New Orleanians,

A couple of weeks ago, I sent out an email about a report the Corps is holding back. It is the final report for the London Avenue canal load test, and it has been delayed for months. In fact the test took place last August. After I sent that email, I heard they are planning to release it before June 15th. We’ll see.

While members of the public and their appointed representatives on the East Bank Levee Authority cannot yet see the report, the Corps is all too content to trumpet the success of the test to their contractors and fellow employees.

Last week, at the Midwest Levee Conference in St. Louis, the lead Corps engineer and project manager from a Corps contractor for the load test gave an extensive presentation about the test. The Conference was co-sponsored by the Society of American Military Engineers (SAME) and the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE). SAME is the Corps’ professional organization for their engineers - kind of their private clubhouse.

You can see the June 3rd presentation on the load test here:

All the presentations are available here.

What I find interesting are the following:

1) No mention of the the external peer review of the test is mentioned, nor of the Levee Board’s insistence on including testing for seepage effects (originally, the test was only going to measure whether the wall moved, not whether water would move underneath it). In fact there’s absolutely no information whatsoever on the locals’ key involvement in ensuring the test was properly vetted. The presentation gives the impression that the Corps did everything themselves, and that they should be congratulated (Actual bullet point from the last slide: “Test was a success. No water through the wall!“). The fact is they had to be pushed into the peer review on the test.

2) Page after page of actual test data are displayed. None of this data has been made available to the public in New Orleans.

3) The last line of the presentation is a laugher: “Detailed results are available for additional study to enhance the engineering understanding of I-wall performance.” Available to whom, precisely? Other Corps engineers and their contractors? What about making the results available to the public whom the Corps is supposedly protecting before they present them to their buddies?

This is just more evidence of the tin ear the Corps has when it comes to dealing with the public. There’s no way this presentation should have taken place before the report was released to the greater New Orleans community.

Matt

Bookmark and Share

Lakefront Permanent Pump Stations Delayed a Year?

June 11th, 2008 by Loki

Once more HumidCity is proud to syndicate the emails of engineer Matt McBride, the man who formerly helmed Fix The Pumps.

Dear New Orleanians,

There have been hints coming out of the Corps for quite a while that the permanent pump stations at the lakefront would be delayed even further than their current 2012 completion date. I think I might have found something conclusive that shows that. I could be off, but you never know…

First, take a look at a schedule of projects the Corps showed at a small business contractors’ gathering on April 23rd (go to page 10):

http://www.mvn.usace.army.mil/ebs/SDVET/SDVET%20Presentations%20less%20SADBU.pdf

The line for permanent pump stations is somewhat jumbled, showing “pre-award” activities extending into the first quarter of 2009, but also showing construction beginning this fall, the third quarter of 2008. I believe the second line, showing construction, is the one that counts. It would seem that construction is anticipated to last 3.75 years, finishing up before June, 2012. This would be in line with most public statements from the Corps.

However, also in April the Corps placed a listing of all their hurricane protection contracts, including future ones, on their website:

http://www.mvn.usace.army.mil/hps/pdf/Upcoming_Contracts/Potential_Upcoming_Contracts_16_Apr_08.pdf

If you scroll to the bottom of page 3, you’ll see the listing for the contract for the permanent pump stations. It is shown as getting awarded in the 3rd calendar quarter of 2009. That would appear to be significantly later - possibly a year after what the other schedule shows. If one assumes the same duration of construction, then a year of delay at the start means a year of delay at the end.

The Corps has publicly promised the permanent pump stations would be done by the beginning of the 2012 hurricane season. However, if the very detailed April 16, 2008 schedule is to be believed, it would appear that:

1) That deadline has been pushed back a year

or

2) The Corps has figured out how to shave a year off the construction schedule.

There have been other subtle hints that the permanent pump stations might get delayed. They include:

- A solicitation issued last month for cranes at the current floodgates included an option for rental of those cranes through the entire 2012 hurricane season. If the permanent pump stations were to be in place by 2012, there would be no need for those cranes. Here’s the solicitation:

https://www.fbo.gov/?s=opportunity&mode=form&id=75973f5a51e052b17f21efe2c6b67698&tab=core&_cview=0

- Also, note Colonel Starkel’s hesitancy at the end of this June 1, 2008 interview on WWL-TV when asked when the permanent pump stations would be finished:

http://www.wwltv.com/video/news-index.html?nvid=250644

His exact words are “we’re looking about 2012.”

- Completion of the Individual Environmental Report for the stations has been repeatedly delayed, with an April public meeting pushed back to July. An article in the Times-Picayune last week mentioned that the report will be delayed again, likely meaning a further postponement of the July meeting (which was intended to outline the contents of the report).

- The Corps transferred most of the appropriated funds out of the permanent pump station project to pay for the Industrial Canal closure project (that contract was awarded in April). The pump station account is currently nearly empty. The replacement funds are tied up in the Emergency War Supplemental bill now wending its way through Congress. President Bush has vowed to veto that bill for reasons unrelated to the Corps funding. The Corps has said publicly that if they don’t have funds on October 1 of this year, projects (like the pump stations) would definitely get delayed.

- Finally, it took the Corps over a year to award the design-build contract for the Industrial Canal closure project. The permanent pump stations are of the same scale, and the Corps does not appear to have begun the bidding process yet.

All signals point to further delays on this project.

If I’m wrong, then the Corps needs to come out publicly and say with certainty that those stations will be there June 1, 2012. They also need to explain why one of their schedules shows a year difference from another of their schedules.

One has to wonder if the stations will get built at all?

Matt McBride

Bookmark and Share

8/29 Commission, Why? Well, Lets See….

June 4th, 2008 by Loki

The video shows why we all need the 8/29 Investigation - a truly independent and complete analysis of the Katrina levee failures on August 29, 2005. Best if done by NOON THURSDAY JUNE 5.

Help launch Levees.Org to the top of the YouTube charts!

Want to do more? You can also:

1. Register at YouTube and rate the video.

2. View and rate our other videos on YouTube.

Help spread the word. Help show why New Orleans and people nationwide deserve the 8/29 Investigation. We have shown that the levee study done by the government is flawed and controversial. We also know that the review done by the ASCE was shoddy and biased.

-Loki, HumidCity Founder

Bookmark and Share

Demand an 8/29 Commission

June 3rd, 2008 by Loki

A bill to find the truth about the levee failures is stalled in Homeland Security and YOU can kick this bill into action!

If you haven’t yet, please make two (2) important phone calls today:

1. Call Senator Landrieu at 202-224-5824 and tell her we need hearings on the 8/29 Investigation Act.

2. Call Senator Vitter at 202-224-4623 and ask for him to co-sponsor Senate Bill 2826 so we have a bipartisan bill.

It’s quick and simple - just start your phone call with this:

“I would like to leave a message for the Senator…. ” And leave your message.

Your Senators represent YOU; make sure your voice is heard!

Best if done by 6pm CST today Tue June 3.

Syndicated from the Levees.org email.

Bookmark and Share

Seepage - and what the Corps is holding back

May 29th, 2008 by Loki

Once more HumidCity is proud to syndicate the emails of engineer Matt McBride, the man who formerly helmed Fix The Pumps.

Dear New Orleanians,

Apparently the Corps New Orleans District is trying to allay fears about leaks through their levees, according to a press conference held today.

“‘We want to put to rest the concerns with seepage,’ Durham-Aguilera said…’We are talking about a way of working collaboratively with the levee authority to decide how to implement peer review, whether to use individuals from academia or a think tank.’”

One of the best ways to do that would be to force the public release of the final report on the London Avenue canal load test, held last summer. That report has already been through independent peer review.

The report’s release has been delayed repeatedly since at least March of this year. At the May 15th East Bank Levee Authority meeting, a member of the Authority asked about the report, and was told by Colonel Bedey it would be out by June 1, which is three days away. Is the Corps holding the report back? Probably so.

The report undoubtedly contains a great deal of information about seepage in existing floodwalls, as that’s what the load test was all about. Getting it released would definitely shine light on what the Corps currently knows about leaks through levees and floodwalls, much more so than a press conference and vague promises of future reviews. They’ve already got the information, so why not put it out there?

Matt

Bookmark and Share

Corps finally Admits: Rusty Pipes Are Bad

May 27th, 2008 by Loki

Once more HumidCity is proud to syndicate the emails of engineer Matt McBride, the man who formerly helmed Fix The Pumps.

Dear New Orleanians,

Those of you who followed my blog might have remembered my post about the 17,000 feet of rusty, unpainted hydraulic pipes at all three lakefront floodgate sites.

For over two years, the pipes have sat there, corroding away in a marine environment. All the while, the Corps did nothing.

Until last Friday, when this solicitation popped up:

New Coating System for Hydraulic Pipes-Cleaning and coating hydraulic and fuel lines Interim Closure Structures-Orleans Avenue, London Avenue, and 17th Street

It’s about time!

When I wrote about the rusty pipes, I only concentrated on the lines between the pump engines and the pumps themselves, which carry 3000 psi hydraulic fluid. I noted, but never wrote about, the fuel lines which feed the generators from the huge, 20,000 gallon fuel tanks. They also are very rusty, and are just as critical to the operation of these facilities.

Finally - FINALLY - the Corps will do the right thing and hydroblast and paint the things. When they will do so is not clear, because the synopsis does not give a timeline. And this will still not correct the problem with inadequate sizing of the pipes. That could only be corrected by replacing them.

The fact this is coming two years after their installation should make people think very long and hard about the reassurances the Corps has given over that period that everything was just fine. Everything was not fine, and it still is not

Matt

Bookmark and Share

Corps Cutting It Close at Floodgates this Year

May 23rd, 2008 by Loki

Once more HumidCity is proud to syndicate the emails of engineer Matt McBride, the man who formerly helmed Fix The Pumps. He is one of our best voices for New Orleans.

Dear New Orleanians,

Last week, the Corps held a public hurricane readiness exercise under the rubric of a simulated storm called “Hurricane Zeus.”

There wasn’t a lot of press attention to it, and the even the Corps hasn’t put out a press release detailing how the exercise went.

However, the Baton Rouge Advocate wrote an article about it.

In there is this paragraph:

“Ray Newman in the operations division of the corps’ New Orleans District said a hydraulic winch system lowers the gates. A backup system for the hydraulic winches and redundant electrical systems ensure continued operation, he said.”

That backup system is a crane to lower and lift the individual gate segments at each floodgate structure. Cranes were used exclusively to lower and lift the gates during the 2006 hurricane season, before the hydraulic winches were installed. A picture of a typical crane is attached.

There’s nothing wrong with using cranes. They are slower than the automatic system, and they generally can’t operate in particularly high winds, but as a backup system, they work fine.

The problem is you have to actually have them at the site. It seems the Corps doesn’t, and is scrambling just days before hurricane season starts to rectify the situation. Read the rest of this entry »

Bookmark and Share

c’est la vie … say levee?

May 22nd, 2008 by PH Fred

well after 2 years in a fema trailer, give or take a few half lives and a couple of missed doses of depakote, i’m finally back in a house. so armed with a contempt for capitalization and punctuation, let me hit the ground punning… as  my head begins to spin into puddles of creativity, i realize the biggest problem with post-k new orleans or post reagan politics isn’t reality, it’s all perception.  my jazz fest experience as a performer made me think that we weren’t in the small print…. all those people opened up for us,,,,  when i recently donated one of my paintings to the grace house for an auction, i didn’t consider myself a starving artist with only 3 pieces sold in my 44 years, rather score now is fred 3, van gogh 1.  

it’s all in the perception… the spin… the lie even.

as i sat recently blurry eyed and pumped with manic endorphins, a piece of “lie” and perception hit me or kicked me or fondled me… it has to do with the reason i’m only recently in a house and may be back in a trailer or a boat or homeless when hurricane season arrives on my freshly unpainted doorstep august or thereabouts: 7400 Leake Ave, New Orleans, LA 70118???? leake ave?  LEAKE?  LEAK?   oh yes, the physical address of the U.S. CORP OF ENGINEERS… c’est levee!  well, as i investigated further the PUBLIC AFFAIRS dept of the corps (or is that corpse????) no longer uses 7400 Leake Ave, New Orleans, LA 70118 as their addy…. they got a P.O. BOX… go figure… you can’t sue ‘em, you can’t find ‘em, BUT YOU CAN STILL BLAME ‘EM.  I suggest they get a new physical addy on TUPPERWARE ST or WATERPROOF RD or ME CULPA DR or better yet on WE ADMIT IT WE F’D UP ROYALLY AND WE PROMISE WE WON”T LET IT HAPPEN AGAIN BLVD.

a p.o. box? you gotta be kiddin’ me!

 

BLOG THIS!

p.h. fred (phfred@notthat.com)

?

Bookmark and Share

Bad News: Its Not Just New Orleans

May 13th, 2008 by Loki

This post is dedicated to all of the soulless cretins who denigrated my neighbors and I for moving back to New Orleans. This ones for you!

Most of America has “Katrina Fatigue.” They’re sick of hearing about the minor issues that have displaced half our city. It almost makes me wish I was sadistic enough to revel in this news article, but I’m not and I can’t.

You see the Army Corps of Engineers is not just the source of an overflowing cornucopia of woes for the Crescent City, oh no! Their pernicious incompetence ranges far further than that, at least if you believe….MSNBC:

ST. LOUIS - Across America, earthen flood levees protect big cities and small towns, wealthy suburbs and rich farmland. But the Army Corps of Engineers, the federal agency that oversees levees, lacks an inventory of thousands of them and has no idea of their condition, the corps’ chief levee expert told The Associated Press.

The uncertainty, amid an unusually wet spring that has already caused significant flooding across many states, is creating worry even within the corps.

“We have to get our arms around this issue and understand how many levees there are in the country, who’s watching over them, what populations and properties are behind them,” Eric Halpin, the corps’ special assistant for dam and levee safety, said in an interview last month. “What is the risk posed to the public?”

Critics are troubled that the government doesn’t know the answer.

Its disturbing on a level that New Orleanians are all too familiar with. And it makes me come back to an old mantra of mine I have not voiced in awhile: “We must not let this happen to anyone else.”

If there is a lesson to be learned from the Levee Failure that followed Katrina it is one that has been lost to the members of modern American sound-bite culture. Not everyone, but enough of a percentage that I run across them frequently whenever I travel north and visit anyplace else in the country.
Go read. Especially if you are from somewhere else. Trust me, you do not want to experience what we did in August of 2005.

Really, you don’t.

Bookmark and Share

Corps Can Be Sued For MR-GO, Judge Rules

May 3rd, 2008 by Loki

DSC02872

In the midst of the Jazz Fest Daily Deluge the following article snuck through between the raindrops:

A federal court judge cleared the way Friday for the Army Corps of Engineers to face trial on claims that defects in its Mississippi River-Gulf Outlet destroyed wetlands and turned the navigation channel into a funnel for storm surge..

U.S. District Judge Stanwood Duval’s 40-page ruling “paves the way for the first and only trial that will likely be held on how the Army Corps of Engineers drowned New Orleans” during Hurricane Katrina, said California attorney Pierce O’Donnell, who leads the legal team that filed the case two years ago on behalf of a group of plaintiffs that includes WDSU-TV anchorman Norman Robinson, who lived in eastern New Orleans.

The suit alleges the controversial shipping channel flooded thousands of homes in eastern New Orleans, the Lower 9th Ward and St. Bernard Parish.

After the way previous suits against the Corps have gone this is a lovely breath of fresh air. In order to engender respect from the community there needs to be responsibility, accountability and some from of pennance besides. Accountability has been evaded because of decades outdated immunities still on the books. Need I remind the world yet again that the winds that hit New Orleans were Cat 2, we were on the weaker backside of the storm. The levees were certified for Cat 3.

Now the Corps is using newspapers to seal the gaps in the levees? Drag them through the court system and enforce accountability.

Without proper flood protection the world will lose a lot, not just the residents of New Orleans. Newsweek said it very well recently:

This subtropical port, which looks to the Mediterranean, Africa and the Caribbean for inspiration, has always marched to the beat of a multitude of different and very funky drummers. Which city has more beguiling street names - Abundance, Beaujolais, Cupid, Desire? Other places have the Rotary and the Elks. New Orleans has Social and Pleasure clubs and the Mardi Gras Indians - African-Americans masquerading as Native Americans in a tradition dating from when Indians and slaves were natural allies. A Mardi Gras Indian designs and sews a new costume every year: one chief put the cost, in time and materials, at $100,000 each. There are secret rituals, songs and chants; even parade routes are classified. Masking is crucial - disguise, misdirection, all in the service of nutty, impractical, unclassifiable mystery - and it’s one key to understanding the city and its culture. New Orleans elevates the chores of daily life to a high level of culture. Porch railings are wrought into sculpture. In the kitchen, the humblest food becomes piquant. Even the funeral procession is an art form.

In the wake of Katrina, New Orleans is doing what it does best: making something extraordinary out of next to nothing. There’s no Marshall Plan here - just small miracles in individual neighborhoods. “The culture of New Orleans emanates from the bottom up, not from the top down,” says Ellis Marsalis, pianist, composer and patriarch of the musical clan. The resurrection of the neighborhoods is doubly important because thousands of residents are still trying to come back, and because the city’s culture - particularly its music - is anchored in the neighborhoods. Unless they are revived, “the music won’t have a home anymore,” says saxophonist Donald Harrison Jr., who is also the Big Chief of the Congo Nation, a Mardi Gras Indian tribe. “New Orleans needs the neighborhoods, because it’s the only city in America that retains its traditional styles.”

In the increasingly mobile and digital age the world needs places like New Orleans. This is the last true American bohemia in so many ways, a place with a rich and vibrant (and yes, in many case unfortunate) history.

This is one of those rare moments of sanity over the past three years, I hope it goes the distance!

Now back to my foul weather Jazz Fest Blogging

Loki, Founder and Cat Herder, HumidCity

Bookmark and Share

Van Antwerp finally blogs about New Orleans

May 1st, 2008 by Loki

Once again HumidCity is proud to syndicate the bulletins of Matt McBride. Formerly the Blogger of Fix the Pumps fame, this engineer with an eye for details is our city’s best defense against the outright and life threatening dishonesty of the Corps of Engineers. Ladies and gentlemen, Matt McBride! -Loki, Founder and Chief Blog Wrangler, HumidCity.

https://eportal.usace.army.mil/sites/Blog/Lists/Posts/Post.aspx?ID=23

He talks about rebuilding trust with New Orleanians. He also says that New Orleans is the Corps’ top domestic priority. Then why wasn’t his Tuesday visit to New Orleans trumpeted all over the local media? In fact, the only mention I could find came in the middle of a NY Times article about the Qatari Emir’s visit on Tuesday.

“Sheik Hamad said he was particularly touched by what happened here, as he explained in halting but resourceful English, in an interview at his hotel…Sheik Hamad, not used to the attention, submitted patiently to questions while aides swirled about him. Lt. Gen. Robert Van Antwerp, commander of the Army Corps of Engineers, came to visit. Then it was off, police sirens blaring, through the streets of New Orleans.”

Compare that to the enormous attention Van Antwerp got during his well-choreographed two day visit on the eve of the 2007 hurricane season, when he held a press conference on the Old Hammond Highway bridge in front of the 17th St canal gates. That produced a front page article inthe T-P and TV stories galore.

This time, there wasn’t even a press release from the Corps’ own New Orleans office.

Considering that the Qatari Emir was not in town to see earthworks, but hospitals, schools, and housing, I think it may have just been coincidence Van Antwerp met with him. Or perhaps he wanted to talk about base construction in Qatar. But it seems likely that if Van Antwerp really wanted to make a big deal of his visit to New Orleans and rebuild trust, he could have. But he didn’t.

Matt

Bookmark and Share

Corps Category 5 Study Released: Late and Useless

March 15th, 2008 by Loki

This content is syndicated from the email by Matt McBride, formerly at the helm of Fix The Pumps. -Loki

Dear New Orleanians,

The Corps has released the preliminary version of their category 5 study:

http://lacpr.usace.army.mil/default.aspx

or the direct link:

http://lacpr.usace.army.mil/default.aspx?p=LACPR_Draft_Technical_Report

They had promised this to the public (after missing their 12/31/07 deadline) on February 8th, as seen here:

http://www.mvn.usace.army.mil/pao/Video/WLAE_Col_Lee_080115.wmv

I went and checked on March 7th, and it hadn’t yet appeared on the LaCPR site. But it’s there now.

By the way, the study doesn’t actually make any recommendations. In fact, here’s an excerpt from the end of the report:

“Efforts to date do not point to a single effective risk reduction strategy. No single strategy for comprehensive hurricane damage risk reduction, other than entirely abandoning communities in South Louisiana, will guarantee safety for the population along the coast.”

Basically, what this study has done is just collect all the alternatives, so that more meetings can be held. The Corps has placed a paragraph in the report meant to blunt criticism that the public was expecting recommendations from this report, and there are none (and, yes, I am aware that was reported earlier, but that doesn’t mean that every member of the public in South Louisiana will remember or care about it):

“Congress also directed a technical report rather than a reconnaissance or feasibility report as described by normal USACE policy. The technical report will contain many of the same components as a reconnaissance or feasibility report, such as presenting the results of the formulation and evaluation of alternatives. As outlined by the Congressional direction, the technical report will contain a ‘comprehensive hurricane protection analysis and design…to develop and present a full range of flood control, coastal restoration, and hurricane protection measures…for comprehensive Category 5 protection.’”

Expect to see that argument when people start asking, “why are there no recommendations other than, ‘have more meetings?’”

Matt

Bookmark and Share

Corps of Engineers Blog!?!?

February 21st, 2008 by Loki

According to Matt MacBride, a man my hat is always tipped towards, the head of the Corps of Engineers, Lt. General Robert Van Antwerp, has started a blog:

https://eportal.usace.army.mil/sites/Blog/default.aspx

There is only one post up so far, and it is about Iraq not the Gulf Coast. Still, I think it is damn important that we all take advantage of the opportunity to at least have our say in a new public forum

I know I will be stopping by with pointed questions, and I hope that people from around the U.S. (perhaps folks who live near those 137 levees that are not up to snuff across the country) chime in as well.

[EDIT: here is a link to the Corps Press Release and here is an alternate link if the one above does not work -loki]

Loki
Founder, HumidCity

Bookmark and Share

Reduced Consequences of System Failure NOT Improvements to the System

November 9th, 2007 by Loki
Syndicated via email from Matt McBride:
This past June, the Corps of Engineers released a bunch of maps from their never ending Risk & Reliability study:
Back then, no mention was made as to when the actual study behind the pretty pictures (which showed that the system on June 1, 2007 was hardly any better than on August 28, 2005) would be issued. That study is Chapter 8 of the Corps’ official investigation into Katrina, called the IPET study.
This past Tuesday, the Corps snuck Chapter 8 on to the IPET website (https://ipet.wes.army.mil/). There was no fanfare, press conferences, coordinated press strategy or anything. Perhaps that’s because of verbiage like this (from the executive summary):
“The effectiveness of the repairs and improvements made to the hurricane protection system
can best be measured by comparing the predicted inundation elevation-exceedance relationships for the Pre-Katrina HPS and Current HPS. The risk analysis results show that moderate inundation reductions have been achieved for more frequent events of less than 0.01 probability per year, but that predicted inundation elevations are mostly unchanged, and there is still significant risk of inundation for less frequent storms.”
and this (from Appendix 13, Consequences):
“While the HPS has been repaired and improved dramatically over the Pre- Katrina HPS, the risk associated with the Current HPS to the area is still considered to be high for extreme events if the pre-Katrina potential consequences are used in the analysis. The risks to life and property would be expected to be reduced if existing demographics and redevelopment values were used, however the reduction would be due entirely to the reduced consequences of system failure and not due to the improvements to the system. In any case, the human and economic risks to New Orleans would be considered high during exteme events.”
None of this is particularly news. However, what really got my gander up is another sentence from Appendix 13:
“The actual direct damages incurred due to the hurricane exceeded $28 Billion and the loss of life was more than 700.”
The loss of life was WAY more than 700, and it has a number. Accounts vary, but it seems to be closer to 1400 or 1500. The official dead and missing total from the state of Louisiana (http://www.dhh.louisiana.gov/offices/page.asp?ID=192&Detail=5248) is 1464 dead in Louisiana, with an additional 135 missing.
Since I’m not a member of a federally-funded team of researchers with the resources of the entire government at my disposal, I can’t be certain of the exact number. However, the authors of this study have had over two years to get that sentence correct, and instead they choose the course that just happens to play into the interests of the Corps of Engineers.
Who else has an interest in minimizing the horrific toll taken by Katrina? The fact that behavior like this continues over two years after the storm is galling.

Matt

Bookmark and Share

WhistleBlower Discovers (SURPRISE!) The Pumps are Faulty

October 11th, 2007 by Loki

So this did not seem to make the news in the splashy way it should have. More lies and incompetence from the people who hold our lives in their hands. Maria Garzino is a hero, and should be treated as such. I encourage you to read on and see what the latest from the Corpse of Engineers holds:

WASHINGTON, DC, October 9, 2007 (ENS) -  The main pumps protecting New Orleans in the event of a major hurricane or flood are “inherently flawed” due to poor design and still have not been properly tested, according to whistleblower disclosure documents released today by Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility, PEER.

The top U.S. Army Corps of Engineers specialist assigned to oversee the city’s new pumping system says that key safeguards were circumvented and “there is an erroneous assumption that…hydraulic pumps are fully operational, and hence, the risk to the public remains high,” in the words of the U.S. Office of Special Counsel.

Maria Garzino, a veteran Corps civil engineer, who was the team leader of pumping systems installation for New Orleans, has filed for federal whistleblower status with the U.S. Office of Special Counsel, OSC.

In a September 21 letter, the OSC notified Defense Secretary Robert Gates that it found Garzino’s charges credible.

Writing from the OSC’s office, Scott Bloch informed the defense secretary, “I have concluded that there is a substantial likelihood that the information she provided to the Office of Special Counsel discloses violations of law, rule or regulation, gross mismanagement, a gross waste of funds, and a substantial and specific danger to public health.”

By law, Secretary Gates must respond within 60 days.

Bloch’s letter states, “My office has received serious allegations which cast doubt on the integrity of costly pumping equipment installed in three main structures by the USACE and its ability to protect New Orleans from further flooding.”

The three structures are located at 17th Street, Orleans Avenue, and London Avenue.

Read the rest at the original Environment News Service Article!

If my lunch hour were not dwindling so rapidly I would write more. Watch for future posts!

Bookmark and Share