Posts tagged Army-Corps-of-Engineers

USGS Does The Right Thing, While Corps Doesn’t Share

August 29th, 2008 by Loki

Dear New Orleanians,

While the Corps of Engineers refuses to give up its storm surge prediction results, other branches of the government are not nearly so stingy.

The U.S. Geological Survey USGS), obviously a far more open, service-oriented organization, is setting up real-time surge level monitors on the shore of Lake Pontchartrain and other places around the New Orleans area starting tomorrow (Aug 30) as Gustav approaches. The public will be able to track what happens in the lake and elsewhere across the metro region in real time.

Not only that, but they are making the data available to the entire world via a super-easy Google Earth interface, available here.

There’s more detail in this USGS press release.

Here’s the USGS’s complete Gustav page.

Meanwhile, here’s the Corps’ online efforts in advance of Gustav, a self-congratulatory newsletter of use to no one.

Great job USACE! That’s far more informative than storm surge predictions…Matt McBride

DC Endangered by Crappy Levees, Go Figure

July 25th, 2008 by Loki

A reader in Cincinnatti, OH who used to live in New Orleans Pre-Katrina graced my in-box with the following email message. I will write about this later once I have more time. In the meantime the RadiantAchangelus pretty much sums it all up:

Wait, Washington D.C. is below sea level? And filled with historic monuments? And barely protected by crappy old levees? Gee, sounds like a city I know. But quick - don’t fix the levees - they should just move too!!

Gaps in aging levees leave D.C. landmarks exposed - Yahoo! News

Of course if that is not enough here is a teaser from the article itself:

The small berm is part of an inconspicuous levee system designed to protect world-famous museums, the National Archives and federal office buildings from flooding.

But the nearly 70-year-old levee is at risk of failing during a major storm — a catastrophe that could swamp portions of downtown in up to 10 feet of water and cause $200 million in damages, according to federal officials.

Dozens of communities coast to coast are facing similar warnings as authorities re-examine the nation’s outdated flood-control infrastructure.

And one final ominous bit of foreshadowing I was heretofore unaware of (emphasis mine):

During six previous floods, officials placed sandbags on 17th Street, which cuts across the National Mall near the Washington Monument. Had there been more serious flooding, plans called for erecting an 8-foot earthen embankment with dirt taken from the grounds of the Washington Monument, said Steve Garbarino, the Corps’ project manager for flood protection in the Washington region.

This is Your Nation. This is Your Nation surrounded by failing levees. Any Questions?

Thanks R! We miss you down here!

stop me if you’ve heard this one before

June 20th, 2008 by Louis Maistros

Yes, please do stop me if you’ve heard this one before. Because the punch line stinks.

Spoiler alert:

(photo by Louis Maistros, copyright 2006)

The italic bits are from the Associated Press, June 14, 2008. Stay with me. I’m trying to sort this out for myself as I go.

The dark, filthy water that flooded Iowa’s second-largest city finally started to recede Saturday after forcing 24,000 people to flee, but those who remained were urged to cut back on showering and flushing to save the last of their unspoiled drinking water.”

This does sound familiar, but keep going, maybe it’s just kinda-sorta familiar but not really.

“President Bush was briefed on the flooding in Iowa and other parts of the Midwest while he was in Paris, and was assured that federal agencies are making plans to help people affected by the high water…”

Yes, this does ring a bell. Because I remember how it was ok to do very little, way too late, or, really, nothing at all, as long as a person in a position of ultimate authority told us they have been officially assured by some vague figure employed by a vaguely referenced government agency that someone who knows someone is most assuredly (if vaguely) making plans to do something, vaguely, about this currently very specific and not vague-at-all problem that’s destroying lives, homes and families right here in the good old USA even as I type this. It’s like a memory of a dream of a memory of a plan of a dream of plan of a plan. Shit, I’m getting dizzy here. But wait, there’s more…

“He expressed his concern for people who may still be in danger and for those who are hurting from the impact of the storms…”

Yes, I clearly remember a fleeting warm fuzzy feeling that manifested itself in the midst of a traveling nervous breakdown. It hit me fuzzily on the road to God knows where after hearing widespread reports of genuine heartfelt concern from the president – but the feeling came and went so quickly I’m not sure if it was real or a dream now. Keep going, it’s a sort of déjŕ vu, but I need to be sure…

“The levee broke in two places,” said Keithsburg Alderman George Askew, 76. “We’re getting under water.”

OK, this part I remember.

“Since I’ve been involved in public office we’ve not seen this kind of devastation,” Obama said of the Midwest flooding. He vowed to push the federal and state governments to provide needed aid to the stricken areas.

Oh, Senator Obama; you wound me, sir. You know I love you, baby, but I’m pretty sure you were “involved in public office” in August of 2005. But thank you so much for noticing the Iowa flood, and for vowing to “push” for help there, and I hope you remember this one in three years time. I hear you even filled a few sandbags for the cameras – you’re catching on quick to this campaign trail stuff; good for you. If only you remembered about the 2005 thing, if only anyone “in pubic office” remembered, maybe things would be going a little smoother over in Iowa right now. You know, all that “we must learn from history or be doomed to repeat it” horseshit?

“Things happened really fast,” said Toby Hunvemuller of the Army Corps of Engineers. “We tried to figure out how high the level would go. Not enough time. We lost ground.”

Yes, that I remember as well. These things do happen very fast, don’t they? It’s why all these vague plans and preparations need to be a little less vague. But still, it’s nice to know the folks in charge of this stuff are at least very concerned. Really, all that concern after the fact just fixes everything right up. In fact, all you need is love. This must be true because I heard it in a song once.

And here is that stank-ass punch line that I hoped never to hear again, or, as my friend John Doheny says, the money quote:

“Authorities knew the aging levee near Birdland, a working-class, racially diverse neighborhood, was the weakest link among the city’s levees. A 2003 Corps report called for nearly $10 million in improvements across Des Moines, but there wasn’t enough federal money to do all the work.”

Bada bing, bada bang, bada boom. And there it is. Total recall. Just like here, they knew this was coming and did nothing. Even AFTER what happened here, so freshly in everyone’s minds, knowing full well how bad it can get.

The real kick in the pants is that, according to the “Corps Report” mentioned by AP, all Iowa needed to prevent this heartbreaking disaster was $10 million. Does that seem like a lot of money? Guess what, its’ not. Louisiana needs billions. $10 million is chicken feed. Bill Gates lost $10 million dollars while sneezing this morning and didn’t even miss it. It came right out his left nostril along with a Cheerio or two. This could have been prevented with relative ease.

There was “not enough federal money to do all the work?”

The war in Iraq costs US taxpayers $341.1 million dollars PER DAY.

All Iowa needed was $10 million to prevent catastrophic flooding that the authorities KNEW was bound to happen. 10 million dollars is the equivalent of a 20 minute coffee break in “the war on terror.”

Does widespread devastation at home not count as “terror”? For chrissakes, will someone get a cup of coffee already?

Are we really that much more afraid of a handful of psychopaths armed with box cutters than we are of a potentially endless series of ticking time bombs built by our own government and planted on our own soil?

You know, we in the gulf region like to take a small comfort in believing that what happened here in 2005 might not have been in vain if only those in power were to take the lesson learned, do their goddamn jobs, and try very hard to make sure it doesn’t happen again – here or anywhere else.

My heart goes out to the people in Iowa whose lives have been needlessly devastated this past week. I won’t play the “our disaster was bigger than your disaster game” because that game is bullshit. If you lost a loved one, or a home, or a livelihood, then you can give a rat’s ass about the statistics. It’s just a bunch of fucking numbers. The bottom line is this: it happened. And it didn’t have to.

One can only hope that the levees in Iowa are at least not stuffed with old newspaper as they apparently are here.

I hate to say what I feel I must say. Forgive me, but here it is:

For those who lined up to laugh at and mock the people of New Orleans for their “stupidity” in living in a city below sea level, who said shit like, “why don’t they all just get up and move to higher ground?”, that we should move from a place called home, a place we love, a place that existed and thrived a hundred years before America was even born – can you really look at what happened in Iowa and still believe all or any of that heartless bullshit you threw at us? Wouldn’t it be more productive to simply take a massive crap in your own hat?

The common thread here isn’t in the unpredictability of Mother Nature. The common thread is the bad, incomplete, poorly designed, poorly implemented, and badly kept structures brought to you by our own Army Corps of Engineers. And the jackasses in Congress, in the Senate, and in the White House who refuse again and again to give money back to taxpayers in the form they need it most; towards the basic protection of American citizens in their own homes.

This time it was a levee. Last time it was levee. Next time it might be a bridge. Or a highway. Or a damn. I bet you have one of those near you, wherever you are in America.

The Army Corps of Engineers is immune from prosecution for their actions or inactions; even if the damage is ruled malicious, even if they knowingly create faulty structures; lie about it, then actively covers up these facts. There need to be new laws on the books that hold them, and all government agencies, accountable for their actions. Otherwise they can do whatever the hell they want and thumb their noses at us while they snicker behind our backs and tell us how concerned they are about our shattered lives.

You are probably thinking: What can I do except hope it isn’t me next?

If you really believe there’s nothing you can do, the jig is up. The bad guys win. Game over.

Please don’t ask me for instructions. Use your imagination.

(Note: Click here for the full article quoted in this entry)

***

Cross-posted from These Things May Not Be Right, But They Are True.

http://louismaistros.com


The Sound of Building Coffins by Louis Maistros is due for publication from The Toby Press in Spring 2009.

8/29 Commission, Why? Well, Lets See….

June 4th, 2008 by Loki

The video shows why we all need the 8/29 Investigation - a truly independent and complete analysis of the Katrina levee failures on August 29, 2005. Best if done by NOON THURSDAY JUNE 5.

Help launch Levees.Org to the top of the YouTube charts!

Want to do more? You can also:

1. Register at YouTube and rate the video.

2. View and rate our other videos on YouTube.

Help spread the word. Help show why New Orleans and people nationwide deserve the 8/29 Investigation. We have shown that the levee study done by the government is flawed and controversial. We also know that the review done by the ASCE was shoddy and biased.

-Loki, HumidCity Founder

Bad News: Its Not Just New Orleans

May 13th, 2008 by Loki

This post is dedicated to all of the soulless cretins who denigrated my neighbors and I for moving back to New Orleans. This ones for you!

Most of America has “Katrina Fatigue.” They’re sick of hearing about the minor issues that have displaced half our city. It almost makes me wish I was sadistic enough to revel in this news article, but I’m not and I can’t.

You see the Army Corps of Engineers is not just the source of an overflowing cornucopia of woes for the Crescent City, oh no! Their pernicious incompetence ranges far further than that, at least if you believe….MSNBC:

ST. LOUIS - Across America, earthen flood levees protect big cities and small towns, wealthy suburbs and rich farmland. But the Army Corps of Engineers, the federal agency that oversees levees, lacks an inventory of thousands of them and has no idea of their condition, the corps’ chief levee expert told The Associated Press.

The uncertainty, amid an unusually wet spring that has already caused significant flooding across many states, is creating worry even within the corps.

“We have to get our arms around this issue and understand how many levees there are in the country, who’s watching over them, what populations and properties are behind them,” Eric Halpin, the corps’ special assistant for dam and levee safety, said in an interview last month. “What is the risk posed to the public?”

Critics are troubled that the government doesn’t know the answer.

Its disturbing on a level that New Orleanians are all too familiar with. And it makes me come back to an old mantra of mine I have not voiced in awhile: “We must not let this happen to anyone else.”

If there is a lesson to be learned from the Levee Failure that followed Katrina it is one that has been lost to the members of modern American sound-bite culture. Not everyone, but enough of a percentage that I run across them frequently whenever I travel north and visit anyplace else in the country.
Go read. Especially if you are from somewhere else. Trust me, you do not want to experience what we did in August of 2005.

Really, you don’t.

Van Antwerp finally blogs about New Orleans

May 1st, 2008 by Loki

Once again HumidCity is proud to syndicate the bulletins of Matt McBride. Formerly the Blogger of Fix the Pumps fame, this engineer with an eye for details is our city’s best defense against the outright and life threatening dishonesty of the Corps of Engineers. Ladies and gentlemen, Matt McBride! -Loki, Founder and Chief Blog Wrangler, HumidCity.

https://eportal.usace.army.mil/sites/Blog/Lists/Posts/Post.aspx?ID=23

He talks about rebuilding trust with New Orleanians. He also says that New Orleans is the Corps’ top domestic priority. Then why wasn’t his Tuesday visit to New Orleans trumpeted all over the local media? In fact, the only mention I could find came in the middle of a NY Times article about the Qatari Emir’s visit on Tuesday.

“Sheik Hamad said he was particularly touched by what happened here, as he explained in halting but resourceful English, in an interview at his hotel…Sheik Hamad, not used to the attention, submitted patiently to questions while aides swirled about him. Lt. Gen. Robert Van Antwerp, commander of the Army Corps of Engineers, came to visit. Then it was off, police sirens blaring, through the streets of New Orleans.”

Compare that to the enormous attention Van Antwerp got during his well-choreographed two day visit on the eve of the 2007 hurricane season, when he held a press conference on the Old Hammond Highway bridge in front of the 17th St canal gates. That produced a front page article inthe T-P and TV stories galore.

This time, there wasn’t even a press release from the Corps’ own New Orleans office.

Considering that the Qatari Emir was not in town to see earthworks, but hospitals, schools, and housing, I think it may have just been coincidence Van Antwerp met with him. Or perhaps he wanted to talk about base construction in Qatar. But it seems likely that if Van Antwerp really wanted to make a big deal of his visit to New Orleans and rebuild trust, he could have. But he didn’t.

Matt

oops we did it again (dam it!)

October 30th, 2007 by PH Fred

so according to bush and the gang, the california wildfire will not be the same as the katrina debacle (insert: “bush likes white people, he really really like rich white people”)… implied are all sorts of slams, glares, and nannie nannie boo boos at blanco et alia.

BUT i’m not going to go there… i have one bigger and better in a Malthusian (oh crap, you gotta be joking kinda way)… according to MSNBC the mosul dam is on the brink of failing… and with it a trillion gallons of water would flood Iraq… california 8 people, new orleans 1800, iraq (get this) 1/2 million… i’m sure this dam was fine until we started blowing up our enemies in order to liberate the oppressed… well b4 we can give you democracy, do you mind taking a bit of a bath? estimates….mosul 65 feet of water, baghdad 15 feet

and guess who’s in charge of making sure its fixed.., the army corps of engineers? neither army nor apparently engineers… and we know how much they know about building or rebuilding dams and levees in the sand…

so do you think the rest of the mideast would be that forgiving if bush and the gang did to iraq what they let happen to new orleans?

BLOG THIS!

ph fred (phfred@notthat.com)

Why Is The Corpse Witholding A Critical Report??

May 31st, 2007 by Loki
Dear New Orleanians and those interested in our city,
Some of you may know that the new head of the Corps, General Van Antwerp, is in New Orleans today, and has a press conference scheduled for 4 PM.
Some of you may also know that the Corps has had an internal investigation of the design, installation and operation of the floodgate pumps underway since last September. In a May 2, 2007 letter to Senator David Vitter, now-retired Corps Commander General Strock publicly revealed the existence of this investigation. He said the investigation would be complete sometime during May. He also said the investigation would be turned over to the GAO so that their inquiry would be robust.
Today is May 31. The Corps internal investigation has not been released. It has not been turned over to GAO, who issued their findings last week. If GAO had received the Corps internal investigation, they would have mentioned it, but they didn’t. They never got it, because the Corps didn’t turn it over to them.
Now it appears the Corps is not going to release it until Van Antwerp has a chance to see it. Back channel sources are telling me the delay is also to avoid embarrassing Van Antwerp during his visit to New Orleans. Tomorrow is hurricane season. The citizens of New Orleans deserve much more than political games by Corps Public Affairs Officers. If there is something deeply damaging to the Corps in the report (and my money is on “Yes,” or else it would have come out by now or it would have been turned over to GAO before their May 15th deadline), everyone needs to see it, now.
If any of you know anyone who is to attend this afternoon’s 4 PM press conference with Gen. Van Antwerp, I beg you to have them ask hard about this internal report, and why the Corps feels it is more important to withhold potentially embarrassing information rather than informing the citizens who depend upon their work.

Matt McBride
http://fixthepumps.blogspot.com

Oh Happy Day!

February 2nd, 2007 by Loki

NEW ORLEANS - Residents whose homes were flooded during Hurricane Katrina can sue the Army Corps of Engineers over claims the agency ignored warnings about defects in a nearby navigation channel, a federal judge ruled Friday.

The ruling, one of the first significant decisions in a set of cases over what caused the flooding, may force the Corps to hand over documents about the management of the channel. (via yahoo news)

I had given up hope for this! The unassailable position of immunity that the Corps(e) has held is finally getting some scrutiny and action!

The Corps and federal government had argued they were immune to legal challenges because decisions about the waterway were based in policy.

But U.S. District Judge Stanwood Duval said there is no way to know that at this point, and said plaintiffs should get a hearing for their allegations.

Is that the tiniest flickr of hope I feel begining to ignite? Stanwood Duval is my new hero, one I’m sure will enter our peculiar local pantheon. Now the question is, will the suit have a chance?

powered by performancing firefox

Levee Failure, When Will We Have Some Responsibility?

May 30th, 2006 by Loki

Forensics report on Levee Failures

A group of forensics experts led by some professors from UC Berkeley released a damning 738-page report on the levee failures during hurricane Katrina. They found a system that was “pervasively flawed” (surprise, surprise), and said that the failure was at all levels of government, including the Feds, the local levee board, and to a lesser extent the Army Corps of Engineers.

Go check it out as an audio report at the link above, go on, I’ll wait. Well Christian Roselund gets thanks for putting this out there. I doubt we will see any accountability, after all why break a solid trend? We keep re-establishing the fact that no level of government did their job, yet no real repurcussions are felt. It is absolutely nauseating.

As Memorial Day receeds I ponder the fact that my father did time in a Viet Namese prison camp to defend this country only to have it abandon us.